Two Jewish Guys Walk Into a Church and Kick a Catholic Out of His Pew
That's what Russ Roberts and Tyler Cowen did on this week's Econtalk when they assured listeners Montaigne didn't believe in the Catholic God (Blog Post)
I think it's a case of what social psychologists call a "conversational feedback loop." Two guys already lean in the same direction, start talking, and travel further and further in that direction, until they reach incorrect, yet mutually-agreed-upon, conclusions.
Here, Roberts and Cowen start by questioning whether Montaigne believed in a Christian God. They banter, until Cowen caps it off with assuring everyone that there's no way Montaigne believed in the Catholic God.
Russ Roberts: Yeah. I mean, I agree that there's nothing Christian as far as I understand it in this writing, but it's not... He invokes God a lot. That's all I meant. He's not-
Tyler Cowen: Sure. I strongly think he believed in God, but doubted it was a Christian God.
Russ Roberts: Or an organized religious God.
Tyler Cowen: Certainly not a Catholic God.

But it's not true. Montaigne worshipped, and when friends and family apostatized to Protestantism, he didn't. There's also the awkward fact that he apparently revered the House of Loreto:
[Montaigne] made that pilgrimage to see the Holy House of Loreto in 1581. He spent three days there, went to Mass, listened to pilgrims’ tales of miraculous cures, and left behind three silver figurines (representing his Secular Family) as an ex-votos offering. Carlos Eire, Reformations

Now, in defense of Roberts and Cowen (two men I follow and enjoy), I suppose they were limiting themselves to Montaigne's actual writings, which were highly skeptical in general, so their conclusion is understandable from that perspective. And maybe they aren't acquainted with details of Montaigne's life, even though Roberts strongly recommends a new biography of the world's first essayist.
Aside
The Cotton translation of Montaigne's essays has grown a bit stale with age.
Supposedly, the Screech edition is far easier on contemporary ears. I haven't read it, but I have added it to my Christmas list.

